How editors handle sensitive material

We chatted with IVP Senior Editor Eleanor Trotter The Plausibility Problem, a book that IVP felt was important to publish knowing that there would be positive responses as well as criticism.

How does a publisher handle a sensitive book and provide the best care to their authors?


1. Why was it important to publish The Plausibility Problem?

A number of Christians are same-sex attracted. They have had to work through difficult issues both biblically and pastorally: if God loves them, then why does he forbid same-sex unions in the Bible?; is it plausible that a loving God should give them certain desires and then forbid the fulfilment of those desires?; how can the church help those who, like the author, encounter loneliness and frustration as a result of following the Bible’s teachings? With same-sex issues prominent in the church as a whole over the past decade or so, and opinions differing from liberal to conservative extremes, IVP needed to publish something wise, biblical, balanced, sensitive and pastorally warm to guide Christians in their thinking.

2. As an editor, how do you approach controversial subjects with diplomacy and care?

We were fully aware that this book would be tricky to write and that feedback would include negative as well as positive voices. Blending truth with grace is always a wise way forward, and we try not to add any offence to the offence of the gospel. Supporting the author was a priority, and we were confident that he had great qualities of shrewdness and diplomacy, as well as a deep Bible knowledge.

3. What do you hope readers take from the book?

An awareness that it is possible to live a fulfilled life as a celibate Christian with same-sex desires. But also, the church needs to recognize its responsibility to be a family to single people, including same-sex attracted Christians, offering love and hospitality.

Related Posts
  1. 6 Things I Loved About the Keswick Convention 6 Things I Loved About the Keswick Convention IVP Senior Editor Eleanor Trotter attended the Keswick Convention last week. Here, she shares six things she loved about her time there. 
  2. Collective belief: an editor's passion for a book that really matters Collective belief: an editor's passion for a book that really matters We chatted with IVP Senior Editor Eleanor Trotter about Dig Deeper, a book that provides readers with tools to engage more fully with the Bible. 
Related Products